Keeper Or Creeper?

So I decided it’s time to start a brand spankin’ new segment.  I LOVE hypothetical questions and playing the dirty, “what if” game.  Needless to say this is perfect for me!  Every Saturday I will put females in odd situations to determine if the guy is a keeper or creeper.  Some will be easy decisions and others may be difficult.  I plan to not make it easy on you!  On the debut today I talked about an extreme case.  Hypothetically you have been on three dates with a guy, let him spend the night already, and everything is perfect!  You are making out one night and notice a lock of your hair on his dresser.  Is this act of weirdness a complete bombing of what you two had built?  Can he be salvaged, can he be a keeper?  Find out what my lovely listeners thought of this below!