Sex and the City: The new class cast?

There has been a lot of talk of a prequel to all-things Sex and the City, that would show the girls pre-adulthood in NYC. Most of the world seems to be pretty against the idea, including Sarah Jessica Parker, but since she wouldn’t be playing her younger self, the creators apparently don’t care.

They’re continuing to move ahead with the idea, and have reportedly been in talks/possibly confirmed that these ladies will be the new cast:

Elizabeth Olsen (lil sis of MK & A) will play Carrie, Blake Lively will be a young Samantha, Selena Gomez as Charlotte, and Emma Roberts as Miranda.

What do you think? Is this prequel a good idea? Did they choose the right girls for the cast?

[polldaddy poll=5292940]